By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Marketing In Asia
  • Marketing
    • Viral
    • Expert Opinions
    • News & Trends
    • Research
    • Market Podcasts
    • Market Videos
    Marketing
    This category deals with best news and updates on marketing and branding news and events.
    Show More
    Top News
    Apple Vision Pro
    Apple Vision Pro: A Revolutionary Leap into Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality
    18 hours ago
    Google ads
    Google Ads Console Experiences Unplanned Downtime
    18 hours ago
    Using Google to search for information
    Google’s Upcoming 3D Product View Feature: Revolutionizing Mobile Shopping Experience 
    19 hours ago
    Latest News
    Garmin Unleashes Feature-Packed Update for Fenix 7 and Forerunner Watches
    17 mins ago
    Sana: The AI-Powered ‘Digital Library of Alexandria’ Revolutionizing Enterprise Information Accessibility
    2 hours ago
    Gentari Welcomes New Chief Marketing Officer: The Next Chapter for Dheeraj Raina
    2 hours ago
    Joanna Cockle: The New Marketing Maven at Villa Finder
    2 hours ago
  • Startup
    • News from Startup world
    • Startup Stories
    • Trends and Opinions
    • Startup Podcasts
    • Startup Videos
    Startup
    News and articles from startup and venture investment world
    Show More
    Top News
    benefits of Venture studios
    Comparing Venture Studios and Traditional VC Firms: Key Differences to Know
    2 weeks ago
    funding
    Matrix Partners India Boosts its Fourth Fund to $525M Amid Economic Uncertainty
    2 weeks ago
    Amit and Gaurav Khatri
    From Basement to Battling Tech Giants: The Inspiring Journey of Two Brothers 
    2 weeks ago
    Latest News
    UBS Gears to Finalize Credit Suisse Takeover by June 12 
    1 day ago
    Shilpa Shetty Fuels Fitness Revolution with KisanKonnect Partnership
    6 days ago
    Open-Source OOH Audience Measurement Framework Unveiled by Regional Advertising Leaders, AAMS, and Moving Walls Group
    1 week ago
    The Rising Tide: Transforming the Scene for Women Entrepreneurs in India
    2 weeks ago
  • Business
    • Feature Stories
    • News
    • Business Podcasts
    • Business Videos
    Business
    News and press releases from business world of Asia
    Show More
    Top News
    Joanna Su Yin Cockle
    Joanna Cockle: The New Marketing Maven at Villa Finder
    2 hours ago
    Mindshare lionel kho
    Mindshare Secures Data Strategy Ace Lionel Kho for APAC Leadership Role
    2 hours ago
    Gifts from TUMI
    Reinventing Father’s Day: Iconic Gifts from TUMI’s Alpha Bravo Collection
    17 hours ago
    Latest News
    Keso Kendall Steps Up as Senior VP of TEAM LEWIS to Lead Operations Across APAC
    1 hour ago
    HKGCC Recommends Labour Importation to Counter Widespread Talent Deficit in Hong Kong
    1 hour ago
    Sana: The AI-Powered ‘Digital Library of Alexandria’ Revolutionizing Enterprise Information Accessibility
    2 hours ago
    Gentari Welcomes New Chief Marketing Officer: The Next Chapter for Dheeraj Raina
    2 hours ago
  • Society
    • Inspiration
    • Destinations & Travel
    • Food & Gourmet
    • People
    • Young Voices
    • Society Videos
    • Society Podcasts
    Society
    News and articles from and for societies around us
    Show More
    Top News
    Blackpink's Rosé Leads K-beauty's Digital Revolution: Sulwhasoo and Lazada Unite for 'Shoppertainment'
    Blackpink’s Rosé Leads K-beauty’s Digital Revolution: Sulwhasoo and Lazada Unite for ‘Shoppertainment’
    1 week ago
    Sari
    The Sari Transformed: A Global Journey from Traditional Garment to High Fashion
    2 weeks ago
    Podcast
    Unplug and Tune In: Top 5 Indian Podcasts for Your Listening Pleasure in 2023
    2 weeks ago
    Latest News
    Revolution In Customer Loyalty: DFS Group’s DFS CIRCLE Transforms Luxury Travel Retail Experience 
    2 days ago
    Immerse Yourself in the Aromatic Extravaganza: Thailand Coffee Fest 2023 
    1 week ago
    MS Dhoni: The Quintessential Leader of Indian Premier League (IPL) 
    1 week ago
    Petronas Unveils Heritage-Rooted Films: A Celebration of Malaysia’s Cultural Richness
    1 week ago
  • Stories
  • Videos
    • Videos Gallery
    • The Opinion Scout
    • Step By Step
    • Market Masters Series
Search
Technology
  • Hot
  • Trending
  • Editor’s Choice
  • NSFW
  • Reactions
  • Authors
  • Viral on Internet
Other Pages
  • My Bookmarks
  • Customize Interests
  • About Marketing In Asia
  • Business Register & Login
  • Startup Register & Login
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
© 2023 Marketing In Asia Sdn Bhd. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly Of Crisis Communication
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Latest News
Gramin
Garmin Unleashes Feature-Packed Update for Fenix 7 and Forerunner Watches
Branding Campaign Marketing
Keso Kendall
Keso Kendall Steps Up as Senior VP of TEAM LEWIS to Lead Operations Across APAC
Business News
HongKong
HKGCC Recommends Labour Importation to Counter Widespread Talent Deficit in Hong Kong
Business News
AI
Sana: The AI-Powered ‘Digital Library of Alexandria’ Revolutionizing Enterprise Information Accessibility
Business Marketing
Dheeraj Raina
Gentari Welcomes New Chief Marketing Officer: The Next Chapter for Dheeraj Raina
Marketing News
Aa
Marketing In Asia
Aa
  • Hot
  • Trending
  • Editor’s Choice
  • NSFW
  • Reactions
  • Authors
  • Viral on Internet
  • My Bookmarks
  • Customize Interests
  • About Marketing In Asia
  • Business Register & Login
  • Startup Register & Login
Search
  • Marketing
    • Viral
    • Expert Opinions
    • News & Trends
    • Research
    • Market Podcasts
    • Market Videos
  • Startup
    • News from Startup world
    • Startup Stories
    • Trends and Opinions
    • Startup Podcasts
    • Startup Videos
  • Business
    • Feature Stories
    • News
    • Business Podcasts
    • Business Videos
  • Society
    • Inspiration
    • Destinations & Travel
    • Food & Gourmet
    • People
    • Young Voices
    • Society Videos
    • Society Podcasts
  • Stories
  • Videos
    • Videos Gallery
    • The Opinion Scout
    • Step By Step
    • Market Masters Series
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2023 Marketing In Asia Sdn Bhd. All Rights Reserved.
Marketing In Asia > Blog > Business > News > The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly Of Crisis Communication
News

The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly Of Crisis Communication

profile
Last updated: 2019/10/31 at 12:00 AM
Leaderonomics
Share
17 Min Read
the-good,-the-bad,-and-the-ugly-of-crisis-communication
SHARE

Author, Dr Eugene YJ Tee

No fewer than five important figures have been attributed to this quote – the most well-known and recent being former United States (US) Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. The same is often said of organisations and their leaders. When an organisation faces a crisis, we see what the establishment and its leaders are really made of.

Crises are situations in which organisations experience a severe shortage of resources, an unforeseen challenge that threatens their financial and reputational standing. An organisation’s – and its leader’s – strengths, character and values, are laid bare under such circumstances.

Crises demand that organisations and their leaders respond promptly and convey a clear sense of direction and purpose that address the trials at hand. Communications to both consumers and stakeholders during this time are make-or-break moments for the organisation.

The ambiguity, uncertainty, and heightened emotions that surround a crisis can rapidly escalate to damaging speculations and accusations. In some cases, these lead to conspiracies, rousing negative perceptions, and long-lasting financial and reputational consequences.

Numerous companies have faced crises and emerged stronger from them. One classic example is Johnson & Johnson’s response to the Tylenol murders in Chicago in 1982. Tampered bottles of Tylenol-brand paracetamol were found to be laced with cyanide, which had claimed the lives of seven people.

The pharmaceutical giant acted decisively, making warning announcements to hospitals and distributors and removing over-the-counter bottles of Tylenol from drug stores across the country. The company cooperated with law enforcement agencies and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in tracing the perpetrator of this crime – acts that earned much praise from the US government.

Contrast Johnson & Johnson’s crisis communication strategy and response with what was shown by the International Federation of Association Football (FIFA).

In 2015, football’s most powerful governing authority was investigated on allegations that nine of its officials were involved in a massive corruption case. The officials were suspected of colluding with businessmen and benefitting from bribes and kickbacks from the multimillion-dollar global sport.

FIFA did not deny that there was corruption in the game – but it did stop short of implicating their officials for their involvement in this wide-scale fraud. They then removed the word ‘corruption’ from its latest code of conduct manual – with the new code stating, “bribery, misappropriation of funds or manipulation of football matches or competitions may no longer be prosecuted after a lapse of 10 years”.

Put more simply: “If you fix a football match and we can’t find enough evidence to charge you within 10 years, you’re free to go.” FIFA defended the revised code by claiming that 10 years would be enough for investigations into match-fixing to be complete and charges to be laid.

In May 2019, one year after this creative rephrasing, FIFA restored the word ‘corruption’ to its code of conduct – but only in response to scathing criticism and pressure from whistle-blowers and other influential authorities.

The good

Cases provide excellent examples and description of what organisations should and – more importantly – should not do in the face of crises. Of importance is how the crisis is conveyed and managed in the eyes of consumers and the organisation’s stakeholders and employees.

Take two recent short-term crises resulting from a less-than-optimal choice of advertisement (ad) as examples. In 2017, Pepsi ‘Live for Now’ ad starring Kendell Jenner provoked controversy by inadvertently undermining the Black Lives Matter movement in the US.

The two-and-a-half-minute short film featured Jenner joining a public rally calling for peace, love and acceptance across people from various ethnicities, races and sexual orientations. Jenner offers a can of Pepsi to a police officer, who accepts and takes a sip from the can. The crowd bursts into fervent celebration.

“If only daddy would have known about the power of Pepsi,” came the fittingly sarcastic response from Bernice King, daughter of civil rights activist Martin Luther King. Agreeing with King’s quip, critics argued that the ad made light of the plight of African Americans, implying that racism and police brutality can be solved by a fizzy drink.

The ad was pulled 24 hours later, with both Pepsi and Jenner apologising and stating that the video “missed the mark” of what it had originally intended.

Another similar advertising misstep was committed by Dove in 2018. In this ad, a dark-skinned woman removes her blouse, ‘transforming’ herself into a Caucasian woman. Critics were quick to point out the inappropriateness of the ad; many saw it as blatantly racist and insensitive, insinuating the superiority of fair over dark skin.

In both cases, however, the companies responded promptly. Both ads were removed from their official webpages and social media channels, and an apology was issued by senior representatives of both companies.

While not everyone found the crisis communication and apologies to be sincere or sufficient, the companies responded within hours of the public backlash – with action and apology. In crisis situations, the organisation needs to be prompt, not rash; responsive, not reactive.

Organisations also need to convey their intention to consumers and their employees as quickly as possible. This was what Pepsi and Dove did right. Neither company responded by defending or denying – or further justifying their ads.

What the Pepsi and Dove commercials also suggest is that companies need to carefully consider the necessity, relevance, and appropriateness of portraying contemporary race, ethnicity, and gender-related issues alongside promoting their products or services.

Any corporate communication or messages need to be especially sensitive to the norms of the current times and be inclusive to today’s increasingly diverse consumer and employee base.

Internally-circulated crisis communication messages need to inform and update employees of leaders’ and the organisation’s actions – conveying an apology and setting a course of action for the critical time that follows.

As far as we can tell, there appear to have been no long-term repercussions – financial or otherwise – on either Pepsi or Dove.

The take-away here? Sensitivity, empathy, and responsiveness to both consumers and employees are essential when communicating during crises.

The bad

On Apr 9, 2017, United Airlines Flight 3411 awaited departure from Chicago O’Hare International Airport. The flight was overbooked, so an announcement was made requesting four passengers to disembark the flight to make way for four airline staff.

Such procedures were standard practice – necessary to accommodate airline staffing and roster requirements (a practice called deadheading). Three passengers, randomly called, gave up their seats. One passenger, 69-year old doctor David Dao Duy Ahn, refused.

The airline’s response to his refusal was nothing short of brutality. United called in security officers, who aggressively manhandled Dao, dragging him kicking and screaming off the flight.

Chief executive officer (CEO) Oscar Munoz defended the airline’s actions, accusing Dao of being “disruptive and belligerent”, issuing what many perceived as a half-hearted apology for the airline’s aggressive actions. Munoz further defended the security officers’ actions, saying that he backed them “empathically”.

He then claimed that such an act was simply to ‘re-accommodate’ passengers – a term that was sharply criticised by those following the story. One journalist said the euphemism was as bad as “alternative facts” – insincere, inaccurate, and a poor attempt at covering up United’s excessive use of force on one of its passengers.

Public relations (PR) experts called United’s response a “fumbling, clumsy one”. Stakeholder backlash to the airline’s crisis and its response was swift and merciless – investors devalued the airline’s market value to a tune of close to USD1bil following the incident.

There was one major problem with United’s response. Dao was in no way disruptive or belligerent. The entire incident was filmed by Flight 3411 passengers on their phones. The videos defended the doctor, and the passengers themselves attested to his good behaviour.

They also univocally agreed that Dao was undeserving of concussions, broken teeth and nose that the security officers left him with. Bowing to public pressure and feeling the financial and reputational sting of a poorly handled crisis, Munoz retracted his earlier statements.

A more conciliatory tone followed two days after the incident, with the CEO apologetically stating, “…no one should ever be treated this way…we will take full responsibility and we will work to make it right.” United’s CEO also claimed that “…it is never too late to do the right thing.”

Except that in crisis situations, it can often be too late; organisations do not get a second chance at making that important first impression. The leader may express empathy towards staff, but insufficiently towards consumers, as was the case with United.

How an organisation responds first to a crisis signals what its core values are and where its focus is on. And in United’s case, the empathy that was shown to Dao 48 hours later was much too late.

The airline could have responded in a manner that exemplified its claimed values: “We respect every voice…make decisions with facts and empathy and celebrate our journey together.” It could have embodied, through its actions, its slogan: Fly the friendly skies.

Instead, it left the incident reeling from a financial repercussion and reputational damage that would reside in the minds of both passengers and investors in the foreseeable future.

Both internal and external parties need to be carefully considered – and the crisis communication message balanced with an understanding of how the organisation’s first response shapes these parties’ perceptions. When communicating in crisis, companies do not get a second chance at a first impression.

The ugly…(and a bit more good)

There is no shortage of ugly – terribly handled crisis situations. One, however, that comes to mind is the Volkswagen (VW) Emissions Scandal that was traced back to 2008. Also known as ‘Dieselgate’ or ‘Emissionsgate’, the scandal involved VW diesel vehicles being equipped with a ‘defeat device’ – a piece of hardware or software that tampers with the emissions controls when subjected to emissions tests.

It’s a pretty nifty little tweak to make if your goal is to pass emissions tests and certify your vehicles as environmentally friendly, which was what VW intended to do. In order to meet the stringent emissions standards set by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), engineers at VW equipped vehicles with software that limited the emission of NOx (nitrogen oxide) – a known cause of lung cancer.

Under actual driving conditions, however, the vehicles emitted more than 40 times the amount of NOx. By some scientific projections, the excess pollution caused by these unknowingly approved, heavy-pollutant diesel vehicles would lead to 59 premature deaths and aggravate respiratory problems for many more.

Investigations into this unethical, deceptive practice were only made known in 2015 – eight years after these defeat devices were installed into the VW diesel vehicles. And at least initially, the crisis was handled terribly.

Then CEO Martin Winterkorn resigned in Sep 2015 when allegations surfaced and investigations commenced. Winterkorn denied any knowledge of the emissions scandal, stating in a video interview that he was “endlessly sorry” for the crisis befalling the company.

Angry customers were ‘compensated’ with USD1000 prepaid credit in the form of a Visa and dealership card – a response criticised by US Democratic senators as being “insultingly inadequate”. The company posted a loss of €1.7bil in the third quarter of 2015 in dealing with this crisis, and the reputational repercussions from this fallout also spilt over into a loss of trust in the automobile.

Adding insult to injury, investigations then later revealed that disgraced former CEO Winterkorn had known about the cheating as early as May 2014. Instantly, allegations that Winterkorn had known and allowed for the cheating scandal to continue further tarnished VW’s image and standing.

Investigations into this crisis and scandal continue at the time of writing, and Winterkorn could face up to 10 years in prison and millions in fines for his corporate criminal role in denying and covering up the scandal.

PR experts criticised VW’s handling of the situation – one calling the web of deceit, lies, “half-truths”, and downright denial one of the worst PR disasters since the 2001 Enron crisis.

And yet, there is still something to be learnt from this scandal, and VW’s subsequent response.

In the years following this crisis, VW worked almost single-mindedly towards regaining both their employees’ and customers’ trust. The company took responsibility for its role in the cheating scandal.

They reached out to employees to seek their feedback, providing them with the opportunity to vent their thoughts and emotions from this fallout. They kept employees in the loop on any updates, not via internal email, but through face-to-face communication.

Recently, the automobile company even made an ad acknowledging the emissions scandal with the tagline, “In the darkness, we found the light” – presented fittingly, to the tune of Simon and Garfunkel’s Sound of Silence.

The company owned up to the scandal, paid its dues (a large chunk of them being legal ones), and, while it took some time, VW now sees continued growth in emerging markets such as China.

The VW scandal tells us that PR responses and crisis communications strategies are crucial in helping save and even improve the company’s long-term standing. This case also shows that how companies respond to crises and how they integrate corporate communication into their long-term strategy can determine if, and when they recover from a major setback.

You Might Also Like

Keso Kendall Steps Up as Senior VP of TEAM LEWIS to Lead Operations Across APAC

HKGCC Recommends Labour Importation to Counter Widespread Talent Deficit in Hong Kong

Gentari Welcomes New Chief Marketing Officer: The Next Chapter for Dheeraj Raina

Mindshare Secures Data Strategy Ace Lionel Kho for APAC Leadership Role

Reinventing Father’s Day: Iconic Gifts from TUMI’s Alpha Bravo Collection

Get Latest Job Updates on Whatsapp and Telegram
SCIKEY Logo
Whatsapp
Telegram
TAGGED: strategy

Sign Up For MIA Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest updates about the Marketing world delivered straight to your inbox.

    By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
    Leaderonomics October 31, 2019 October 31, 2019
    Share This Article
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
    Share
    What do you think?
    Love0
    Happy0
    Joy0
    Surprise0
    Sad0
    Angry0
    Cry0
    profile
    By Leaderonomics
    Follow:
    Leaderonomics is a Malaysian social enterprise dedicated to transforming developing nations through leadership development. We believe everyone has the potential to be a leader who can positively and significantly make a difference in their community and organisation.
    Previous Article tin-communications-launch-boutique-pr-agency-in-singapore Tin Communications Launch Boutique PR Agency In Singapore
    Next Article her.-malaysia-summit-2019 H.E.R. Malaysia Summit 2019
    Leave a comment Leave a comment

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Follow US

    8k Followers Follow
    3.4k Followers Like
    1.1k Followers Follow
    200 Followers Follow
    157 Subscribers Subscribe

    Latest News

    Gramin
    Garmin Unleashes Feature-Packed Update for Fenix 7 and Forerunner Watches
    Branding Campaign Marketing 18 mins ago
    Keso Kendall
    Keso Kendall Steps Up as Senior VP of TEAM LEWIS to Lead Operations Across APAC
    Business News 1 hour ago
    HongKong
    HKGCC Recommends Labour Importation to Counter Widespread Talent Deficit in Hong Kong
    Business News 1 hour ago
    AI
    Sana: The AI-Powered ‘Digital Library of Alexandria’ Revolutionizing Enterprise Information Accessibility
    Business Marketing 2 hours ago

    You Might also Like

    Keso Kendall
    BusinessNews

    Keso Kendall Steps Up as Senior VP of TEAM LEWIS to Lead Operations Across APAC

    1 hour ago
    HongKong
    BusinessNews

    HKGCC Recommends Labour Importation to Counter Widespread Talent Deficit in Hong Kong

    1 hour ago
    Dheeraj Raina
    MarketingNews

    Gentari Welcomes New Chief Marketing Officer: The Next Chapter for Dheeraj Raina

    2 hours ago
    Mindshare lionel kho
    BusinessNews

    Mindshare Secures Data Strategy Ace Lionel Kho for APAC Leadership Role

    2 hours ago
    //

    Get Asia to Notice You

    Quick Link

    • Contact
    • RSS Terms of Service
    • Policies & Standards
    • About Us
    • FAQ
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms Of Service
    • Privacy Policy

    Top Categories

    • Marketing
    • Startup
    • Feature Stories
    • News
    • People
    • Inspiration

    Sign Up for Our Newsletter

    Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

      Marketing In AsiaMarketing In Asia
      Follow US
      © 2023 Marketing In Asia. All Rights Reserved.
      • Disclaimer
      • Terms of Service
      • Privacy Policy
      Join the growing tribe of Marketing In Asia!

      Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest updates, news, videos, podcasts etc..

        Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.